Every kid needs a champion. An adult who will never give up on them.
— TED Talk (2013), "Every Kid Needs a Champion"
One true story
Rita Pierson taught for forty years in low-income schools in the United States. Many of her students opened by telling her they were "not the type who could learn." In her 2013 TED Talk she told one small story that has since traveled through the education world.
A student that year failed a math test badly. By the standard rule his paper would have been marked "-18." She did not write -18. She wrote "+2" at the top and drew a smiley face. The student looked up and said, "Ma'am, this is a failing grade, right?" She said, "Yes, but you got two of them right. You are not everything wrong."
Her point later: "-18" tells a child, you are finished here. "+2" tells the same child, you have a starting point to climb from. Same child, same test, different words in the corner. Whether he opened the book again that week was not a matter of aptitude. It came down to the sentence.
A few weeks after her talk was posted, Rita Pierson died from illness. The video has since been watched over 20 million times.
Our reflection
The "champion" Rita Pierson describes is not the most permissive adult. It is the adult who refuses to accept a child's current failure as who that child is. Those are very different jobs.
The "+2" move looks small but it is a specific intervention. It tells a child who is falling: your next step is upward, not disappearance. Only an adult willing to see the child can say that sentence. Pierson spent forty years teaching other adults how to say it more often.
This is also what Luminis calls a Bole. Not the person who spots the natural champion. The person who refuses to let an ordinary horse decide, on its own, that it is a broken horse.