In the Classroom, Clarity Is the Kinder Move
A class doesn't need every sentence to be a question. State the instruction plainly — it's gentler, and it saves your energy for the moments that actually deserve a question.
Every teacher makes hundreds of "where does this go next" judgments in a day — when to ask, when to state, when to just wait.
Child development specialist Siggie Cohen's observation about parents holds true in a classroom too: dressing a required action as "can you?" invites unnecessary pushback. "Can we quiet down?" "How many times do I have to remind you?" — those aren't questions; they're commands we didn't state.
Her principle: Say What You Mean. Before you speak, ask: what am I trying to communicate? Then say it plainly.
Starting a lesson: not "Are we ready?" — "We're starting. Please turn to page thirty-four."
After a fight: not "Why did you hit him?" — "In our class, we don't hit. You're angry right now, I know — let's find another way to tell him."
Roughhousing in the hall: not "Are you at it again?" — "The hallway is a quiet place. Please come back and try that walk again."
Then when do you ask? — When it's actually worth asking. "What did that story remind you of?" "For that problem, what's the first step you thought of?" "Is there an answer you're not sure of yourself?" — that is where a question does its real work.
Classroom order isn't built on authority. It's built on clarity. A child who knows where the edges are has room left over to be curious, to try, to be wrong.
When you take your energy back from nagging, interrogating, and reprimanding, you can give it to teaching, watching, being with them. That, in itself, is the tenderness the students feel.
from Siggie Cohen